1. Get some scrapbook paper.
2. Dig out your scrapbook patterned scissors.
3. Grab a Halloween paper punch. Find a pretty little shape, like a witchy hat.
Cut the paper with your scissors to a votive height... use the punch to make a shape in the middle, and tape it together at the ends. BOOM. You're done.
I used a shape that had little paper pieces in the middle so I put it on contact paper and adhered it to the inside of the paper. An LED tealight is perfect for lighting it up... is this not the cutest little thing? Even the kids could make it!